History...Yesterday in the Present

New Orleans votes to remove Confederate, Civil War monuments

By Ben Brumfield and Ralph Ellis, CNN

Updated 6:13 PM ET, Thu December 17, 2015

Original story appeared on CNN.

NOLA mayor wants to replace Robert E. Lee statue 03:25

Story highlights

• The city's mayor says the vote was "a courageous decision"
• New Orleans City Council votes 6-1 to remove three statues and one obelisk
• A majority of council members introduced the proposal at the mayor's request

(CNN)A large crowd broke into cheers Thursday after the New Orleans City Council voted to remove four monuments to the Confederacy from prominent places in the city.

The 6-1 vote means officials will take down statues of Gens. Robert E. Lee, P.G.T. Beauregard and Jefferson Davis, President of the Confederacy. An obelisk dedicated to the Battle of Liberty Place will also go.

It's one of the strongest gestures yet by an American city to remove symbols of Confederate history, following a trend in many Southern states to take down the Confederate battle flag.

Historic societies in the 300-year-old city supported the removal of the monuments, and the proposal was introduced by a majority of City Council members.

New Orleans' mayor wants Confederate monuments removed 02:21

Mayor Mitch Landrieu described the move as a "courageous decision to turn a page on our divisive past and chart the course for a more inclusive future."

Council member Nadine Ramsey said New Orleans needed to stop living "underneath the shadows" of monuments to people who supported slavery.

"We need not honor these individuals and moments from the past that do not meet our standards of decency, equality and nondiscrimination," she said.

Council member Stacy Head cast the only vote against taking down the monuments, saying the action would create more division and not solve the city's real problems.

"It will not improve the socioeconomic balance of the city," she said. "If it would make the city more color blind, if it would create more balance, I would sacrifice almost any physical object to get us to that point."

Charleston slayings were a tipping point

17 photos: Charleston church shooting

 

Landrieu said the church slayings in Charleston, South Carolina, moved him to take action.

He'd been thinking about having the symbols of the Confederacy removed for about a year, when a white gunman in South Carolina massacred black worshippers at Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal on June 17. Dylann Roof, the shooter, venerated the Confederate battle flag. And soon after the shooting, calls to remove it from that state's Capitol grounds intensified.

A week later, Landrieu announced the planned ordinance.

He addressed the City Council on Thursday, saying that New Orleans has many monuments, but he wanted these four removed because they are the most important.

"This is the right thing to do at the right time," Landrieu said.

"As we approach the Tricentennial, New Orleanians have the power and the right to correct historical wrongs and move the City forward. The ties that bind us together as a city are stronger than what keeps us apart," he said, according to a City Hall news release.

Monuments called 'nuisances'

The ordinance approved by the council declares the Confederate monuments "nuisances" and called for them to be removed. The statues are unconstitutional, said the proposed ordinance marked Calendar No. 31,082.

"They honor, praise, or foster ideologies which are in conflict with the requirements of equal protection for citizens as provided by the constitution and laws of the United States, the state, or the laws of the city and suggests the supremacy of one ethnic, religious, or racial group over another."

Monument supporters say it's not about race

In July, the city called for 60 days of public meetings to review the proposed ordinance.

Landrieu requested the vote to banish specters of racism. But opponents of the plan steered away from any racial argument.

Keeping the figures of the Confederacy was not about preserving racial injustice, they said, but about honoring figures who fought to protect the city.

New Orleans, which was the largest city in the Confederacy, fell to Union forces in 1862 and was under federal occupation beyond the Civil War's end in 1865.

No place for Lee

One prominent artist who wanted the figures gone also skirted the issue of race. Jazz musician Wynton Marsalis, who is African-American, said that Lee in particular had no historic place in the city.

"This symbolic place in our city should represent a great New Orleanian, or it should be an open space that represents our latest prevail and how people helped us, not a person who had nothing to do with our city and who indeed fought against the United States of America and lost," Marsalis told CNN affiliate WDSU.

Gen. P.G.T. Beauregard was a Louisiana native, and Confederate President Jefferson Davis lived in New Orleans after the war and died there.

Statue has stood since 1884

Lee's statue stands 60 feet high atop a neoclassical column at what was christened Lee Circle in his honor. It was originally called Tivoli Circle. Most Mardi Gras parades snake right past it.

Lee faces north, looking in the direction of his former enemy, and has stood there since 1884, the history department at the University of New Orleans says. Both Davis and Beauregard attended the monument's dedication.

Their statues were erected in the 1910s.

A fourth monument, probably the most contentious, will also be taken down.

6 photos: Evolution of the Confederate flag

The monument to the Battle of Liberty Place commemorates an uprising in 1874 of the White League against federal forces and police in an attempt to overthrow racially integrated governance put in place during Reconstruction.

Former mayors, including Landrieu's father, Moon Landrieu, have attempted to have this monument removed or altered.

When asked what would happen to the removed monuments, Landrieu suggested a park that would reflect the complete history of the city, from before the American Revolution to the present. That park, he said, would be a place where "history can be remembered and not revered."

He said city leaders should consider forming a commission to decide what to do about other monuments.

Council President Jason Williams said, "After a long and thoughtful debate on this issue, I am pleased that we have reached a conclusion. Thank you to all citizens who have participated and made your voices heard during this process. We all may have differing perspectives, but share a common love and concern for the City of New Orleans."

CNN's Catherine E. Shoichet, Andreas Preuss and Joe Sutton contributed to this report.